BAR 34:03, May/June 2008
The Varieties of Christianity
The Christian religion has never been one uniform, homogenous thing. From the beginning there has been variety within the church. The Acts of the Apostles describes a split within the earliest Jerusalem church—between “Hellenists” (Greek-speaking Jews opposed to the Temple) and “Hebrews” (represented by the Twelve) (Acts 6–7). The issue involved the extent to which Christians should continue to observe the Jewish Law, especially when gentiles began to enter the church in Antioch (Acts 11:20).
By about the year 50 there were three basic views represented by different Christian leaders. James the brother of Jesus, who had become the leader of the Jerusalem church, stressed observance of the Law. Peter and some Antiochene Christians required certain minimal Jewish ritual requirements of gentile Christians but allowed for separate meal celebrations for Jews and gentiles; that is, the Eucharistic meal that is central in Christian worship. Paul, the most radical, taught that “Christ is the end of the Law” (Romans 10:4). In the messianic era brought about by the resurrection of Christ, there could be no more ritual distinctions between Jews and gentiles in the church (Galatians 3:28).